The withdrawal of patent infringement proceedings by ZTE and Samsung at the Unified Patent Court (UPC) points to a possible breakthrough in their long-running global licensing dispute. The development follows competing court decisions on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory (FRAND) royalties, a disagreement over a $731 million licensing demand, and nearly two years of litigation across multiple jurisdictions. Although neither company has publicly confirmed the terms of a settlement, the latest court decisions suggest that the dispute may be approaching a commercial resolution.
Two companies withdraw their European patent cases
On 6 November 2026, the Unified Patent Court’s Mannheim Local Division approved the withdrawal of two parallel patent infringement actions involving ZTE and Samsung. The parties also withdrew the associated patent revocation counterclaims, bringing the proceedings to a close.
The court’s decision is particularly notable because neither company requested a ruling on legal costs. In its order in Samsung v. ZTE (UPC_CFI_189/2025), the court permitted the mutually agreed withdrawal of the infringement action and counterclaim for revocation under Rule 265 of the UPC Rules of Procedure.
The development continued on 10 November, when the UPC Court of Appeal in Luxembourg approved the withdrawal of another related infringement action brought by ZTE and Samsung’s counterclaim for patent revocation. The appeal had concerned an earlier decision partially revoking the patent in question.
These are more than routine procedural developments. The parties had spent months pursuing patent claims against each other in European courts while negotiating the commercial terms of a global licensing relationship.
Patent publication and court records establish that the proceedings have been withdrawn. However, neither the UPC orders nor the companies’ publicly disclosed statements establish the financial terms or full scope of a settlement.
How a licensing agreement turned into an international patent dispute
The disagreement began with a licensing agreement signed by Samsung and ZTE in 2021.
The agreement established a cross-licensing arrangement covering cellular technologies, including patents essential to mobile communication standards. Under this arrangement, both companies could access relevant technologies covered by the other party’s patent portfolio.
However, when the agreement approached renewal, the companies failed to agree on the new licensing terms. The existing agreement expired at the end of 2023, setting off a series of legal proceedings.
In December 2024, Samsung approached the UK High Court seeking a determination of the global FRAND terms for ZTE’s cellular patent portfolio. ZTE preferred the Chinese courts to determine the licensing terms and subsequently pursued infringement proceedings in multiple jurisdictions.
The disagreement expanded into patent litigation in Germany, China, the United Kingdom, Brazil and the United States. Both companies also initiated infringement proceedings at the UPC.
The central question was no longer simply whether particular patents had been infringed. It was how much Samsung should pay to access ZTE’s cellular patent portfolio and what licensing conditions would be considered fair.
The $392 million versus $731 million FRAND battle
One of the most important developments came on 1 May 2026, when the UK High Court delivered its judgment in Samsung Electronics Co Ltd v ZTE Corporation ([2026] EWHC 999 (Pat)).
After considering the parties’ licensing evidence, comparable agreements and competing valuation methodologies, Mr Justice Richard Meade determined a global cross-licence payment of $392 million.
The financial disagreement was substantial:
- Samsung’s position: The appropriate licensing payment should not exceed $200 million.
- ZTE’s position: Its proposed licensing payment was $731 million.
- UK High Court’s determination: $392 million.
The judgment followed a detailed examination of the companies’ previous licensing arrangements, including their 2021 agreement and ZTE’s earlier agreement with Apple.
An important part of the court’s reasoning concerned the reliability of comparable licensing agreements. ZTE argued that some of its earlier agreements had undervalued its patent portfolio because of its commercial position and limited experience in licensing its 5G patents.
The court accepted that these factors had affected the earlier negotiations and concluded that adjustments were necessary when determining an appropriate licensing payment.
The judgment also highlighted the difficulty of resolving global SEP disputes through multiple competing court proceedings. Mr Justice Meade observed:
“The profusion of litigation is a symptom of a dysfunctional system.”
This observation captures the wider problem facing the telecommunications industry: companies can agree that a licence should exist but still spend years litigating over which court should determine its terms and how much the licence should cost.
The same day, the Chongqing First Intermediate People’s Court in China also delivered its FRAND decision, finding that ZTE’s licensing offer complied with FRAND principles.
The two proceedings therefore produced important but different judicial outcomes, adding another layer of complexity to an already international dispute.
Importantly, the $392 million determination and ZTE’s $731 million offer should not be confused with the terms of the possible settlement. No publicly confirmed settlement figure is available.
Why the UPC proceedings mattered
The Unified Patent Court became an important part of the dispute because both companies were asserting patent rights against each other in Europe.
ZTE brought infringement actions involving its cellular patents, while Samsung pursued its own infringement claims and patent validity challenges.
The litigation produced mixed outcomes.
In April 2026, the Mannheim Local Division revoked ZTE’s European patent EP 3 905 730 on added-matter grounds and dismissed the corresponding infringement action.
In another proceeding, Samsung’s European patent EP 4 096 288 was revoked by the European Patent Office’s Opposition Division, leading to the suspension of the corresponding UPC infringement case.
Meanwhile, ZTE secured an injunction against Samsung at the Munich Regional Court in April 2026 concerning European patent EP 2 654 356.
These developments illustrate why the European proceedings carried commercial importance. The parties were not simply arguing over licensing rates; they were also exposed to the possibility of losing patent rights, defending infringement claims and facing injunctions.
The withdrawal of the UPC proceedings removes an important part of that litigation pressure.
What does this mean for the SEP licensing industry?
The ZTE–Samsung dispute offers three important signals for companies holding or implementing standard-essential patents.
- Global licensing negotiations remain closely connected to patent enforcement.
A company may seek a global licensing agreement, but infringement proceedings can become an important part of the negotiation strategy. The withdrawal of these actions suggests that commercial negotiations may have progressed sufficiently to make continued litigation less attractive.
- Competing FRAND decisions can complicate international licensing.
The difference between the UK and Chinese proceedings demonstrates the challenges of obtaining a consistent global licensing outcome. Companies must consider different judicial approaches, valuation methods and procedural strategies when negotiating international patent licences.
- Patent portfolios have commercial value beyond individual infringement cases.
The dispute involved questions about comparable licences, 4G and 5G patent coverage, portfolio strength and royalty valuation. These factors demonstrate why SEP licensing is fundamentally a commercial negotiation supported by patent rights, rather than simply a question of proving infringement.
Is the dispute finally over?
The withdrawal of the UPC proceedings is a significant development, but it does not independently establish that every aspect of the global dispute has been resolved.
JUVE Patent has also reported that the parallel proceedings before the Munich Regional Court have been withdrawn, although official confirmation was still pending at the time of its reporting.
The status of the remaining proceedings and the precise terms of any global licensing agreement therefore require further confirmation.
Neither Samsung nor ZTE has publicly disclosed a final settlement amount or the complete scope of a renewed licensing agreement.
Nevertheless, the sequence of withdrawals across the UPC proceedings strongly suggests that the companies may have reached an understanding outside the courtroom.
The bigger industry story is what happens when two major SEP holders and technology implementers can no longer agree on licensing terms: litigation can spread across jurisdictions, produce competing FRAND outcomes and create substantial commercial uncertainty. The ZTE–Samsung development may demonstrate that, even after years of legal conflict, a negotiated licensing agreement can ultimately offer a more practical route forward.
For the global telecommunications industry, the next important development will not simply be confirmation that the cases have ended. It will be the disclosure of the licensing terms, portfolio coverage and commercial structure that brought this dispute closer to resolution.
Sources:
- https://youpc.org/judgments/x900012834
- https://youpc.org/judgments/184691
- https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Patents/2026/999.html
- https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Patents/2026/2235.html
- https://www.juve-patent.com/cases/zte-and-samsung-withdraw-upc-infringement-actions-in-apparent-settlement/
- https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/uk-court-orders-samsung-pay-chinas-zte-392-million-lump-sum-after-patent-trial-2026-05-01/
- https://www.clearygottlieb.com/news-and-insights/publication-listing/competing-global-frand-determinations
- https://www.bristows.com/expertise/litigation/upc/upc-case-tracker/
- https://www.iam-media.com/frandseps





